Shadowscape Review

Buy Now
Twitter
Visit Us
Follow Me
YOUTUBE
YOUTUBE
Instagram

ShadowscapeShadowscape Review

Review by David Lent

Shadowscape is a diceless, dungeon crawl card game that plays like a Euro. 1-4 players can play it either cooperatively or competitively. Curiously, the rulebook says it is for 2-4 players, but the box says 1-4 players. Solo games use the cooperative rules and multi-player games have the option of being either competitive or cooperative. The competitive game plays until the Lord of the Dungeon enters the battlefield and is slain. Afterword, players count up their victory points. However, the cooperative game can end either when the Dungeon Lord is slain or the whisper deck runs out. Your character can never “die” or be eliminated. Everybody lasts until the end of the game. Hence, the monsters in this game can only “wound” you and temporarily disable some of your cards.

The components included in the game are of reasonably good quality and the artwork is good. There are 220 cards of the following different types: fate cards, room cards, hero cards, hero action cards, general action cards, enemy cards, treasure cards, whisper cards, Lord of the Dungeon cards and player aid cards. In addition, there are 98 tokens consisting of enemy, treasure, wound, hero and villain tokens. My only complaint is the Dungeon Lord and character token artwork is small and hard to make out. I used my own miniatures instead of these tokens in the game. NSKN Games sells optional miniatures for all its games in the Mistfall Universe.

Setup of this game takes about 5 minutes or so. First, you lay out 25 dungeon cards in a 5×5 pattern to create the dungeon. Next, you create the whisper deck and lay out 4 whisper cards. After that you shuffle the equipment, general action and whisper decks and lay out 4 cards from each. Then you populate the dungeon with creatures and treasure. Each player chooses a hero card and grabs the 4 hero action cards that go with it. You then check your hero card to see how many fate cards go in your starting hand and draw them.

Each player’s game turn consists of an action and enemy phase. During the action phase, you can move, attack, heal, search and draw fate cards. Each action can be boosted with a fate card that has the appropriate boosting symbol. During this phase, you may also turn in treasures or dead monsters to claim equipment and general action cards. You may also claim one whisper card per turn if you meet the prerequisites. Lastly, you may play a fate card to do what its text says. Each fate card has text for both a cooperative or competitive game so you choose the appropriate line. The problem here is the solo game uses the cooperative text and the cooperative text often has you interact with another player, so many cards don’t add any value to the solo game.

Attacks consist of either magic or melee attacks. They are done the same, except each is boosted by a different symbol. Each monster has a defense value that you have to meet or exceed. To attack, you use an action card with an attack capability and boost it by discarding fate cards with its boosting symbol. I.E. if you are attacking a creature with a defense of 5 using a card that does 2-damage you must boost it with 3 fate cards with the appropriate boosting symbol to succeed.

Searching is the action that lets you take treasure that is in a room. The treasure has a number on it that tells you what search value you need to succeed. Typically, a search card has a search value of 1 or 2, so you may boost it with fate cards with a magnifying glass symbol.

At the end of the action phase, you draw one fate card and look at the bottom of it to see what type of monster activates that turn. Each monster has a set of strange symbols on the top that tell you what direction to move the monster through the dungeon. If the monster enters the room you are in, it does a melee attack against you. Some monsters can do ranged attacks, so they just need to get to a room that is adjacent to you to attack. The monster token says how much damage it does and you can soak up part of it with the armor on your player card. If you have any fate cards with an armor symbol you can discard them to soak up more damage. Any damage that isn’t soaked up causes you to place damage tokens on your cards. Cards with damage tokens may not activate until you heal and remove the damage.

The way to get the Dungeon Lord into the dungeon is to keep claiming whisper cards until the whisper card with 3 shards comes out. Each time you claim one of the four whisper cards on the table a new one replaces it. The Dungeon Lord’s whisper card is near the bottom of the deck, so you need to claim many other whisper cards first. To claim a whisper card, you must meet its prerequisites during that turn first. Sometimes, you have to bring a certain monster to a specific shrine. Other times, you may have to search for a specific value in a specific monster types’ lair. You may also have to possess certain types of equipment before claiming a whisper card.

One last thing I want to point out is that some of the dungeon cards are shrines. When your player is present at one of these, he may get a +1 boost to attacks, healing, armor, etc depending on the type of shrine. The battle shrine does not exist on any of the dungeon cards and the manufacturer says that is a misprint. I simply marked one of the dungeon cards with a penny to denote it was the armor shrine. Apparently, there will be an expansion with the corrected card in the future. One of the whisper cards requires you to go to the battle shrine, so this is a seriously problematic misprint.

When I first tried this game, I played a solo game and lost. At first, I thought the game was too hard, but it wasn’t. I didn’t understand the strategy needed to win. I played 4 more solo games and won all of them. It’s really easy to win once you know what you are doing. The solo rules are a lot of fun, but feel like they need some work. As mentioned before, many of the cooperative effects on the fate cards are useless because they require interaction with another player. In addition, you always know where a monster will move to if it’s activated since the symbols are printed on top of the token. It’s easy to know what dungeon rooms to avoid in order to prevent getting attacked by a monster.


The competitive game is better than the cooperative game. In the competitive game, everyone is trying to get as many shards (victory points) as they can by getting whisper cards and equipment. It’s a race to get the most valuable cards before your opponents. You can also use fate cards to trip up your opponent and send monsters their way, etc. Nice guys will finish last in competitive mode.

What’s my overall opinion of Shadowscape? It’s a fun and a very cleverly designed Euro. However, there is no random mechanic other than the fact that the decks are shuffled, so the gameplay is orderly and very predictable. Enemy movement should never be predictable and combat should always have randomness. If I want order and predictability, I will play chess. A dungeon crawl should have chaos, randomness, surprises and player characters that are mortal. Though, I had a lot of fun playing this game (as did my opponents) I can only rate it as good. However, gamers who are more fanatical about Euros than I would probably give Shadowscape a higher rating.

Buy your own copy here.

Good

  • The game is fun
  • Shadowscape plays fast
  • There are solo rules
  • Can be played cooperatively or competitively
  • The artwork looks good on the components and rulebook
  • NSKN Games answers rules questions really fast

Bad

  • Battle shrine card misprint
  • Box says 1-4 players and rulebook says 2-4 players
  • Coop cards are used for solo play and many require interaction with a second player
  • No randomness other than card shuffling
  • Monster movement is predictable
7.2

Good

Rulebook Clarity - 7.5
Fun - 7
Originality - 7
Component Quality - 7.5
Replayability - 7
Average User Rating Write A Review 0 User Reviews
7
1 vote
Rate
Submit
Your Rating
0

1 Comment

  1. Hi, I know I am late but…. I got a solution for you and the other guys that as me, came asking the same question.

    There is just one shrine for each type of attribute (heal, prepare, etc)

    there are just two dungeon cards that contain a kind of statue:
    One of them has a heal shrine
    The other got no signs

    I just started using that one as a battle shrine.

    This game is very fun, I just wished they published errata or update the manual somehow. There are some rules that were worded very wanky.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

*

Lost Password